Will A Woman Become Pope?
A wave of female pastors may make the Vatican look like a
lonely male bastion
By DAVID VAN BIEMA
Are you kidding? Not in this century, anyway. But let's drop
down the hierarchy a little to a more approachable rank of
shepherd. Forget, for a moment, Catholic or Protestant, priest
or minister. What are the odds that your primary spiritual guide
and mentor will be a woman? Fifty percent, minimum.
That shouldn't surprise anyone who's been paying attention over
the past three decades. In the early 1970s, women streamed into
the seminaries at the same time they were marching into other
white-collar professions. Many, notably the Episcopalians, did
so literally on faith, since their denominations barred female
ministers. Today half the Christian branches, plus Reform and
Conservative Judaism, ordain women. (Islam does not allow female
immams.) The United Methodists count 7,039 female ministers (out
of 44,536 total). In 1999 the small Unitarian Universalist
Association recorded a landmark: a ministry that is more than
50% female. Not every denomination will pack so many X
chromosomes into the pulpit, but with female attendance at
seminaries now at 33% and rising, ordinations will follow.
Won't the feminization of mainline Christian denominations
simply drive more traditional churchgoers to Evangelicalism? No
doubt, at least in the short run. Yet there are feminist
undercurrents in conservative places as well. To be sure, in
1984 the Southern Baptist Convention passed a resolution
sanctioning women's service "in all aspects of church life other
than...leadership roles entailing ordination." But the
convention cannot dictate to individual congregations, and the
number of ordained Southern Baptist women has increased each
decade. Although most females attending Baptist seminaries (up
to 40% at some schools) have no intention of targeting a
pastorate, many other Baptist women have enrolled in more
liberal denominations' schools.
Something more subtle is afoot elsewhere on the traditional
right. Pentecostalism, while it shares the Baptists' scriptural
conservatism, relies heavily on the workings of the Holy Ghost,
which are as likely to touch a woman as a man. Women seldom
preach unaided, but Jim and Tammy-style co-pastors are common.
And while megachurches may seem the creatures of their
high-powered male senior ministers, the bulk of their
person-to-person spiritual business is done not on supercrowded
Sundays but in dozens of small weekday prayer, study or
self-help groups--often led by lay women.
It is here that the feminist impulse merges with an equally
dynamic strain in American religion: the empowering of the
laity. All sorts of Christians (and Jews and Buddhists) are
tempering the CEO model of leadership with one that allows
churchgoers to be pastoral counselors or high-ranking
administrators. Again, women have rushed to fill the gap.
Which returns us to Catholicism. The Second Vatican Council of
1962-65 set off what religion futurist Richard Cimino calls "an
explosion of lay ministry." This, plus a persistent priest
shortage, caused some parishes to approximate a female
pastorate. Circuit-riding priests would stop by a church to
celebrate Communion and hear confession. In between, however,
women--church trained and often called pastor--ran the parish.
Eventually there were at least 300 such arrangements (some say
there were thousands), but after John Paul II's 1994 letter
banning further talk of ordaining women, the movement tailed
off. The Pope's decree, however, did not affect "spiritual
directors," one-on-one religious tutors who have thrived since
Vatican II. Many of them are women.
"If present trends continue, the chances that your spiritual
director will be a woman are 70%," says Emory University provost
Rebecca Chopp. She means the term broadly, to include the whole
range of religious authority: Catholic and Protestant, ordained
and lay, trans-denominational (like chaplains) or outside
denomination all together. It may seem a bold prediction. But it
merely suggests a nation where religious leadership will more
closely reflect the population in its pews.